5 Benefits to Pistol Mounted Optics

Image with Mantis TitanX with Pink Rhino Red Dot installed.

Over the years it has become more and more common to see pistols equipped with red dot sights in addition to the traditional iron ones.  We see them on every size and style of gun and used by a wide variety of people.  These electronic red dot sights are not just for professionals, they are very popular with the competition and range crowds as well as with citizen defenders on their everyday carry guns.  There are even dedicated dry fire training red dots like our new Pink Rhino Red Dot.  We will likely continue to see the rise and innovation of these sights as they are shifting to become the default with many manufacturers as well.

So what exactly are red dot sights?  First and foremost, they are a good idea and should not be considered “cheating” in any way.  Technology is constantly innovating and red dots are definitively helping people be better shooters.  Don’t knock it till you try it.

Image with pistol with a pistol mounted optic mounted

A red dot is a small electronic sight system that is mounted to the top of the slide and generates a little shape onto a piece of glass that serves as an aiming designator for the shooter.  This little shape, called a reticle, is typically a dot or a dot with a larger circle around it and comes in a variety of sizes.  Most often they are red, but can be green or even gold.  They can be open which means it has one piece of glass and the emitter is open to the elements, or closed in which case they have 2 pieces of glass and are boxier in shape closing the emitter off to the elements.

Red dot sights (RDS) go by many names, like Miniaturized Red Dot System (MRDS), Pistol Mounted Optics (PMO), reflex sight, micro red dots and dot.  For the purpose of this article we will refer to them as red dots in general and are not specifying any brands, reticle patterns, colors, or compatibility with guns.  Each of those specifications are up to the shooter to decide on based on their firearm and general use case.

It is important to note that while they are highly popular and most would agree are a better way to shoot, traditional iron sights should always be taught and understood first.  You will notice that the vast majority of guns with red dots on them still have iron sights mounted as well, they even get changed out to ensure you can see them in the window.  These are back up iron sights that will allow the gun to continue to be used in an accurate fashion even if the electronic red dot fails.  And they do fail, this is gear you will want to spend more on for improved reliability.

Another aspect worth pointing out is that a red dot is not a laser, while it has some similarities, the red dot is something that is only visible to the shooter when it is properly aligned in front of the shooter's view point.

For most shooters, once they grasp the concept of a red dot, they rarely go back to irons, but that knowledge isn’t lost nor is the skill, in fact many shooters feel learning the red dot improves their iron skills.  Let’s take a look at the advantages of red dots and why most shooters are making the switch.

5 Benefits of using a Red Dot

1) Target Focused

Image depicting pistol iron sights versus a pistol mounted optic overlayed on a criminal to show visibility gains

One of the biggest advantages of using a red dot is that your attention gets to stay fully target (or threat) focused.  Traditional iron sights have three focal planes, rear sight, front sight, and the target.  With a front sight focus methodology this means the target is blurry.  

There are a few problems with this, first being that it goes against how our eyes work in everyday life which makes it hard for people starting out to learn to focus on that second focal plane which leads to many people shooting with one eye closed.  

The second focal plane focus, and possibly one closed eye, means that our situational awareness is being limited.  Did this person pull out a phone or a gun, or is it a toy gun?  That can be hard to determine when blurry, but add in distance and even worse some panic, that can easily lead to mistakes.

Being target focused and having one focal plane simplifies the aiming process for our brains to understand and execute.

2) Easier on the Eyes

Due to having one focal plane red dots are easier on the eyes, they work naturally with our binocular vision.  This allows us to keep both eyes open, focus on the target and ultimately results in quicker visual processing and less eye strain.

Since the focal shift isn’t yo-yoing back and forth between the front sight and the target, the muscles in our eyes and our visual processing aren't working in overdrive for extended periods of time.  For many this leads to longer and more comfortable shooting sessions. Plus by cutting out an entire focal plane shift we are cutting out a step in transitioning from target to target, we simply look from one target to the next with hard focus and let the firearm follow.  The red dot should land at the spot you are aiming, specific and small aiming points will give your red dot an anchor point to transition to immediately.

Image describing how using an occluded dot requires using stereoscopic vision to overlay the dot on the target with both eyes open

As mentioned, our situational awareness stays high with not only target focus but use of both eyes and our peripheral vision.  One of the key pieces of processing we lose under stress is the use of near focus, making front sight focus a difficult task.  It also allows our eyes to work as normal in various lighting conditions with the red dot often being more eye-catching and easier to lock on to than night sights.

3) Faster Target Acquisition

This single focal plane leads to faster target acquisition when used properly and the red dot is consistently presented in the window.  The presentation and grip need to allow for the red dot to appear each time the gun is fully extended out, and to return to the shooter’s view after recoil. 

When done properly the red dot will enter into view from the same position during presentation and will track through recoil in a consistent manner leaving the shooter with a predictable sight picture.  Shooters can then look at a precise aimpoint on the target and know that the red dot will appear in the place they are focusing, this eliminates the focal shift and processing steps of using front sight focus.  Less steps and easier to process information results in everything in the shot process happening sooner, and sooner is faster.  

It is important to note that the red dot does not need to be positioned in the center of the housing and lens, it can be anywhere on the lens as long as it is in the correct spot on the target.  This reduces the need for perfect alignment like irons have and gives a much more generous aiming zone.  Dots allow for multiple levels of confirmation to happen extremely quickly, but they do need to be congruent with the target size and distance as well as the shooter's skill level.

Image of target with Vision, Connection, and Control triangle and 3 confirmation levels listed.

4) Sight Tracking

Part of the faster target acquisition is doing so during recoil, due to being threat focused and the red dot being a bright object that moves in a predictable manner it gives visual feedback for easy shot calling.  

The shooter should not be looking at the red dot itself, but should stay aware of it during the shot process.  Being able to see how the dot moves during recoil and finding that it bounces or leaves the window in a consistent manner means you can shoot again as soon as it is back on target, it does not have to settle or be a clear ball of light.  It should move in some vertical orientation with the recoil and drop back to the spot it started in when the fundamentals are being properly applied.  


This additional visual feedback, during live or dry fire, gives a clue as to how your shooting technique influences the gun as you move.  If your grip is changing, hand/body tension heightens, or trigger control is poor you will see the dot expose that during each presentation, shot, and transition.

5) Critical Hits Happen More Often

With a little bit of practice all of these red dot benefits add up to having critical hit shots happening more often.  While there is a learning curve even shooters new to red dots will report seeing their red dot more often than the front sight in stressful situations and will use less shots overall to create more hits on a target's critical zones.

Starting in 2011 Aaron Cowan of Sage Dynamics has been doing an ongoing study on the use of sights in force on force situations.  With the example of an irons vs RMR study conducted in 2011 at Norwich University, where 95%+ of shots fired hit the target, Sage Dynamics hypothesized that the use of red dots in force on force would yield better overall hit results. 

In 2014, the Sage Dynamics study began to specifically look at the use of red dots in force on force in which 24 students went through four scenarios with traditional or red dot sights.  The experience with red dots by the students was minimal if any.

According to the study “there is a large discrepancy that favors the MRDS (red dot) in the number of critical hits. It’s also worth noting that the number of rounds missed is nearly twice as high with iron sights.”
Image with bar chart showing total shots, total hits, critical hits and misses for pistols with optics versus iron sights
The critical hits were mapped onto a human body to show where they landed, with the red dots showing more significant clusters of hits in the center of the red critical hit zone.
Image showing human silhouette with shot placements from iron sighted pistol data from front, back, right and left sides.Image showing human silhouette with shot placements from pistol with optic data from front, back, right and left sides.
While the Norwich University study showed an overall higher total hit percentage for both irons and red dots, the study was conducted on paper targets, which removed a large portion of stress from the shooters.  When Sage Dynamics applied this comparison to force on force scenarios it was concluded that “The data points to a significant trend towards the MRDS being a superior method of aiming for accuracy in more realistic conditions than what has been gathered previously with students working on paper.”

The study goes into depth not only on the conducted scenarios but in how our brain and eyes work in stressful situations and why red dots work well and result in better accuracy during those situations.  Each of the benefits previously mentioned and more are supported and discussed.

Switching to a Red Dot is Worth it

Making the switch to the red dot does come with an investment of money and time but it is clearly worth it.  The advantages are immense and when a quality red dot is purchased and full understanding of how to use it is implemented, it can drastically improve the speed and accuracy of your shooting.  

When it comes to a stressful shooting situation, we are naturally going to be target or threat focused, seeing our iron sights during that time is hard enough but there are loads of other conditions that can make it even more difficult.  Use technology to your advantage and make the shooting process easier for your brain and eyes.  

Ultimately, we all want to be good shooters when the time comes, whether that is a class, match or defensive encounter so stack the deck in your favor and take advantage of technology and your biology for more critical hits when it counts.

Stay tuned for part 2 where we discuss learning to use a red dot from the ground up and how Mantis products can help.



Kayla House
Kayla House

Author